In the exciting world of 2025’s new cars, the appeal of a shiny, brand-new vehicle is undeniable, promising modern features and a fresh driving experience. However, as a savvy shopper, it’s essential to look past the initial dazzle and consider the long-term realities of owning a car.
At Consumer Reports, our primary mission is to empower you with unbiased, data-driven insights to help you make the most informed purchasing decisions. We understand that a new car is a significant financial commitment, and avoiding potential pitfalls can save you considerable stress and money in the long run. Not every shiny new car on the dealer lot is a smart investment, as some models have reliability concerns, others depreciate faster than you can say “trade-in value,” and a few are simply outclassed by rivals that do everything better for the same price.
With competition fiercer than ever in the 2025 landscape, the margin for error in vehicle design, performance, and long-term value is slim. To help you navigate this complex market, we have identified 15 vehicles that, based on various expert analyses and reported trends, you may want to think twice about before purchasing brand new. Our detailed examination will highlight why these models could end up being more headache than highlight, ensuring you make a choice that truly serves your needs and budget.
1. **Nissan Altima**The Nissan Altima, once a ubiquitous presence in the mid-size sedan segment, now finds itself in a challenging position, often feeling conceptually stuck in the middle of a fiercely competitive class. While it does offer the commendable advantage of optional all-wheel drive, a feature particularly beneficial for drivers in snowy climates, this positive aspect struggles to overshadow other significant drawbacks that buyers should consider.
One of the most frequently cited concerns with the Altima is its continuously variable transmission (CVT). Drivers often describe the CVT as uninspiring, contributing to a driving experience that lacks the responsiveness and engagement found in many contemporary rivals. Furthermore, the Altima’s cabin interior, despite various updates over the years, still lags behind the refinement and material quality offered by segment leaders such as the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry, impacting overall owner satisfaction.
When it comes to reliability, consumer feedback often points to minor but persistent electronic and trim issues, which can be quite bothersome over time and signal a general inconsistency. Furthermore, for the Altima, depreciation is a significant financial concern, as market trends indicate a potential loss of up to 45 percent of its value within just three years, which can be a substantial financial setback.
2. **Jeep Compass**The Jeep brand is synonymous with rugged off-road capability and adventurous spirit, but for the Compass, this strong brand reputation does not always translate into excellence for daily driving. While its styling may appeal to Jeep loyalists who appreciate its visual connection to the brand’s more hardcore offerings, shoppers primarily looking for a reliable and enjoyable small SUV in 2025 may find it falls short in crucial areas.
Owners frequently report a significant lack of lustre when it comes to acceleration, particularly from the standard 2.4-liter engine, which can feel underpowered in various driving situations. This is often coupled with uninspired handling characteristics, making the Compass less engaging or nimble to drive compared to segment rivals such as the Mazda CX-5, which offers a more refined and dynamic driving experience.
Beyond performance, there have been complaints regarding early transmission issues reported by some owners. Additionally, concerns have been raised about premature wear on interior materials, which can detract from the ownership experience over time and potentially lead to unexpected repair or replacement costs. In a crowded small SUV market, consumers can often find more compelling options that deliver a better balance of performance, reliability, and interior quality for their money.
3. **Mitsubishi Mirage**For buyers prioritizing the absolute lowest upfront cost, the Mitsubishi Mirage often appears as an option, being one of the cheapest new cars available. However, the adage “you get exactly what you pay for” holds particularly true here, and in some instances, buyers may even feel they receive less than their minimal investment suggests. This subcompact hatchback embodies extreme cost-cutting measures that significantly impact the driving experience and overall value proposition.
The vehicle’s three-cylinder engine often finds highway speeds challenging, making it difficult and noisy to merge or keep up with traffic, and unfortunately, the road noise is so pronounced that it can make conversations or listening to the radio a struggle, turning every journey into a less comfortable experience.
Furthermore, the Mirage offers minimal safety technology compared to its competitors, which increasingly offer advanced driver-assist systems as standard or affordable options. In an era where safety features are becoming paramount, the Mirage’s offerings feel dated and insufficient. Compounding these issues is its rock-bottom resale value, meaning that despite its low purchase price, owners will likely incur a significant financial hit when the time comes to trade it in or sell it, negating much of the initial savings.
4. **Ford Edge**The Ford Edge has historically offered a comfortable ride and generous interior space, appealing to families and those seeking a practical crossover. However, as the 2025 model year approaches, the Edge’s design is undeniably aging, and Ford has been notably slow to refresh it. This lack of timely updates places it at a distinct disadvantage against newer, more technologically advanced rivals in the mid-size SUV segment.
Buyers in 2025 will quickly notice that many competitors now offer a more comprehensive suite of advanced driver-assist features, which are becoming standard expectations rather than luxury add-ons. The infotainment system, while functional, also feels less cutting-edge compared to the more intuitive and feature-rich systems found in rival vehicles. Moreover, the Edge’s fuel economy figures tend to lag behind those of its newer competitors, leading to higher operating costs over time.
Adding to the list of concerns, whispers from the automotive industry suggest Ford might be discontinuing the Edge, a move that could significantly affect its future resale value and potentially complicate parts and servicing availability for owners looking for long-term reliability.
5. **Chevrolet Malibu**The Chevrolet Malibu, for many years, has been appreciated for its comfortable ride quality and a notably roomy interior, making it a suitable choice for families or individuals who frequently transport passengers. Its appeal has largely rested on these foundational attributes, providing a straightforward and generally pleasant experience for drivers who prioritize comfort over sportiness or cutting-edge technology.
However, a critical factor for prospective 2025 buyers is Chevrolet’s explicit announcement of plans to phase out the Malibu. This impending discontinuation introduces a significant risk for those considering a purchase. Owning a discontinued model can lead to a variety of challenges, including potentially shrinking aftermarket support as manufacturers shift focus to newer product lines. This could impact the availability and cost of parts, making repairs more complicated or expensive down the road.
Furthermore, the Malibu has historically seen high volumes of fleet sales to rental companies and corporate entities. While this doesn’t directly affect the car’s initial performance, it does have a tangible impact on resale values. Vehicles heavily utilized in fleet operations often experience weaker resale values compared to those primarily sold to individual consumers, meaning that owners might not recoup as much of their investment when it’s time to sell or trade in their Malibu.
6. **Dodge Journey**The Dodge Journey stands out as a vehicle whose underpinnings are strikingly ancient, a characteristic that makes it a problematic choice in the modern automotive landscape. Despite its deeply outdated architecture, the Journey regrettably still appears in some markets, often at clearance-level prices designed to entice budget-conscious buyers. However, this seemingly low entry cost belies a host of significant compromises.
Its outdated platform fundamentally lacks modern safety technology, which is a critical consideration for any new vehicle purchase in 2025. Features like advanced driver-assist systems, now common even in entry-level segments, are either entirely absent or rudimentary in the Journey, putting occupants at a disadvantage. Beyond safety, the vehicle’s fuel economy is notably poor, leading to higher ongoing ownership costs compared to more efficient contemporary crossovers.
Moreover, the interior of the Journey feels notably outdated, reminiscent of a 2010 design, with materials that appear cheap and a fit and finish that doesn’t meet today’s standards, often leading even dealership staff to recommend newer models due to its significant shortcomings.
7. **Chrysler 300**The Chrysler 300 has long embodied a particular vision of the American sedan: big, comfortable, and available with rear-wheel drive and optional V8 power, characteristics that undeniably appeal to a specific segment of the market. However, the core challenge for the 300 in 2025 is that its design has barely changed in over a decade, making it a relic in a rapidly advancing industry.
While its imposing design might appeal to some, the lack of recent upgrades means its technology feels decidedly behind the curve, with infotainment systems, connectivity, and driver aids often lagging far behind competitors, which can be a major frustration for those accustomed to modern car features.
Furthermore, the traditional V8 engine options, while powerful, contribute to high fuel costs, which are increasingly a concern for consumers. In an era where fuel efficiency is a significant selling point, the 300’s thirst for fuel makes it a less economical choice for daily driving. Coupled with steep depreciation, this model represents a significant financial commitment that may not offer strong long-term value. Unless a buyer specifically desires the old-school American sedan vibe above all else, there are undeniably better, more modern options available in 2025.
Navigating the 2025 automotive market demands a keen eye, and our journey through vehicles that might present more challenges than advantages continues. Having explored the initial set of cars, we now turn our attention to eight more models that, despite their varied appeals, carry significant drawbacks ranging from unproven new technologies to considerable long-term ownership costs and an uncertain future.
Our detailed analysis, grounded in rigorous testing and consumer advocacy, aims to equip you with the knowledge to make truly informed decisions. We delve into issues like significant depreciation, unproven new technologies, and potential long-term ownership challenges that can transform a seemingly attractive purchase into a source of frustration. The goal is to highlight why these remaining vehicles might not be the best investment for your hard-earned money in the competitive 2025 landscape.
8. **Volkswagen Arteon**The Volkswagen Arteon presents itself as a stylish and comfortable vehicle, particularly for highway cruising, and its aesthetic appeal is undeniable. However, this model faces a substantial challenge in the market, primarily stemming from its status as a slow seller. Low sales volume can significantly impact the ownership experience, a crucial factor for discerning buyers.
One of the most pressing concerns for prospective 2025 buyers is Volkswagen’s announced decision to exit the Arteon from the North American market. Such a move invariably leads to limited aftermarket support as the manufacturer shifts focus away from the discontinued model. This can translate into higher prices and reduced availability for parts and specialized servicing in the long run, adding unexpected costs to ownership.
Furthermore, the Arteon suffers from brutal depreciation, a significant financial consideration for any new car purchase. Consumer reports indicate that some three-year-old models can lose nearly half their original value. This rapid decline in resale value means that the initial investment depreciates at an accelerated rate, making it a less sound financial decision compared to vehicles with stronger value retention.
9. **GMC Canyon**The latest redesign of the GMC Canyon has brought about noticeable improvements in technology and style, aiming to modernize its appeal in the competitive mid-size truck segment. However, this modernization has come with a significant increase in pricing, pushing the Canyon into a territory traditionally occupied by full-size trucks.
This elevated price point raises questions about the Canyon’s value proposition against its rivals. For a similar cost, buyers can often acquire a better-equipped Toyota Tacoma or a Honda Ridgeline, both of which boast stronger reliability records and established reputations. Such alternatives offer a more proven track record and potentially greater peace of mind for long-term ownership.
Moreover, the new platform underpinning the latest Canyon redesign is relatively unproven in the market. While new platforms often promise advancements, they also carry an inherent risk. Early adopters of the Canyon could inadvertently become ‘beta testers’ for any unforeseen mechanical issues or design flaws that may emerge after prolonged real-world use, leading to potential inconveniences and repair costs that might not be covered under standard warranties.
10.Ford’s initial foray into the electric SUV market with the Mustang Mach-E generated a lot of excitement, representing a significant commitment to EVs, but some owners have voiced concerns about a number of issues that have unfortunately marred the ownership experience.
Among the most frequently cited concerns are software bugs, which can lead to frustrating glitches in the vehicle’s advanced systems. Inconsistent charging performance has also been a point of contention, with some owners experiencing variability in charging speeds and reliability across different charging networks. These factors directly affect the practicality and convenience of daily EV use.
Adding to these challenges is the unpredictable nature of the EV resale market, which is still maturing and can be highly volatile. Owner reports have specifically mentioned infotainment glitches and frustrations with the charging network infrastructure, highlighting a gap between expectation and reality. With new EV competition continually emerging, the Mach-E faces the risk of being quickly overshadowed by models offering more refined software, consistent charging, and a more predictable long-term value proposition.
11.The Infiniti QX50 aims to impress with its stylish luxury design and unique variable-compression turbo engine, which promises advanced performance and efficiency, yet in real-world driving, the execution has often fallen short of these high expectations, leading to a less than satisfactory ownership journey for some.
Owners have frequently noted issues such as jerky power delivery, which detracts from the smooth and refined driving experience expected from a luxury vehicle. Additionally, the infotainment system has been reported to suffer from lag, making interactions with essential vehicle functions less intuitive and more frustrating. These operational shortcomings can diminish the overall premium feel.
Compounding these performance and technology issues is the QX50’s significant depreciation, making it one of the fastest-falling luxury SUVs in terms of value retention. When pitted against rivals from established luxury brands like Lexus and Acura, which often deliver better long-term ownership satisfaction and more consistent reliability, the QX50’s value proposition becomes less compelling for the discerning luxury buyer.
12. **Chevrolet Blazer EV**Bearing the name of a storied legend, the Chevrolet Blazer EV entered the market as an anticipated electric crossover. However, like many first-year electric models, its debut has been accompanied by a series of reports from early buyers regarding various production and performance inconsistencies that warrant caution.
Among the reported issues are panel fitment problems, which can be an indicator of manufacturing quality control challenges. Furthermore, owners have noted inconsistent range performance, where real-world driving distances do not always align with stated estimates, leading to range anxiety and affecting trip planning. The availability and reliability of charging infrastructure in certain regions have also posed practical challenges.
As with any brand-new electric model, purchasing the Chevrolet Blazer EV in its early stages carries the inherent risk that the manufacturer is still working out production bugs and fine-tuning its systems. Consumers should be aware that they might experience initial teething problems that could require dealership visits and potentially impact the convenience and satisfaction of their ownership experience.
13. **Nissan Leaf**Once celebrated as a pioneering and affordable electric vehicle, the Nissan Leaf now finds itself struggling to remain competitive in a rapidly evolving EV market. Its initial advantages have been largely eclipsed by the advancements seen in newer electric models, positioning the Leaf as a vehicle that feels increasingly left behind.
Key among its limitations is its comparatively limited range, which often falls short of the capabilities offered by contemporary EVs that can travel significantly farther on a single charge. Another major concern is the lack of liquid battery cooling, a design choice that can lead to accelerated battery degradation, particularly in warmer climates, impacting the vehicle’s long-term battery health and resale value.
The Leaf’s cabin design also feels dated when compared to the modern, tech-forward interiors of many newer electric vehicles. This combination of limited range, a less advanced battery thermal management system, and an older interior aesthetic means the Leaf struggles to compete effectively with newer EVs that offer superior capability, comfort, and advanced features, making it a less compelling choice for 2025 buyers seeking cutting-edge EV technology.
14. **Jeep Wrangler 4xe**The Jeep Wrangler 4xe, with its plug-in hybrid powertrain, represents an intriguing attempt to combine the iconic off-road capability of the Wrangler with improved fuel efficiency. Conceptually, it offers a compelling blend of rugged adventure and environmental consciousness, yet its real-world performance has presented some notable discrepancies and potential challenges for owners.
One of the primary concerns revolves around its real-world fuel economy, which owners have reported often fails to match the optimistic EPA estimates. This gap between advertised and actual efficiency can lead to higher-than-anticipated operating costs, potentially negating one of the key benefits of opting for a hybrid vehicle. Buyers seeking significant fuel savings may find themselves disappointed.
Furthermore, some owners have reported various electrical quirks associated with the complex hybrid system, which can manifest as unexpected operational issues. A more significant consideration for long-term ownership is the potential for high repair costs should the intricate hybrid system fail outside of warranty. At its premium price point, prospective buyers should carefully weigh these potential ownership complexities against the benefits, considering whether a traditional Wrangler or alternative adventure SUVs might offer a more straightforward and reliable experience.
15. **Maserati Grecale**The Maserati Grecale enters the luxury SUV market with undeniable visual appeal, promising Italian flair and performance in a smaller package. However, early production reports suggest that this beauty might come with its share of challenges, particularly concerning reliability and build quality, which are paramount in the luxury segment.
Early owners have reported a variety of glitches with the electrical systems and infotainment, pointing to potential inconsistencies in the software and electronic components, and concerns about the overall build quality have also surfaced, which can diminish the premium feel and lead to unexpected problems.
Compounding these potential reliability issues are two significant financial considerations: heavy depreciation and a smaller dealer network. Maserati vehicles are known for considerable value loss over time, and a limited service infrastructure can make maintenance and repairs more inconvenient and potentially more expensive. For these reasons, ownership of the Grecale could quickly become frustrating, making it a less advisable choice for those seeking consistent luxury and long-term peace of mind in 2025.
The 2025 car market is brimming with choices, but as this analysis shows, not all new vehicles offer the same value or reliability. We’ve carefully examined these 15 cars to provide you with the honest facts needed to make an informed decision, helping you avoid potential pitfalls like steep depreciation, unproven technology, or known reliability issues, so you can invest wisely and truly enjoy your next drive.
