Calling all ice cream aficionados! That special ache only a true dessert lover understands hits hard when your favorite flavor disappears from the freezer aisle, leaving you with a frozen ghost of treats past.
Ice cream companies are constantly pushing the boundaries of flavor, bringing us wild and wonderful concoctions that mix and remix every cookie, cake, and pie imaginable. From the classic comfort of chocolate and vanilla to the adventurous spirit of bacon and garlic (yes, really!), the shelves are a playground for our taste buds. But with great innovation often comes great sacrifice, and sadly, many of these delicious delights don’t make the cut in the long run.
Whether it’s to make room for the next big thing, a seasonal promotion that just couldn’t stick, or perhaps even a supplier issue, dozens of amazing ice creams have been sent to the dreaded “flavor graveyard.” We’re talking about the ones that still haunt our dreams, the flavors we’d trade almost anything to scoop just one more time. So, buckle up, because we’re taking a tasty, bittersweet trip down memory lane to revisit some seriously beloved ice cream flavors that we may never, ever see again.
1. **Klondike Choco Taco**Let’s kick things off with a true legend, a rhyming favorite that brought joy to ice cream truck patrons and bodega customers across the United States for nearly four decades. Imagine this: a crispy waffle cone wrapped around creamy ice cream, shaped just like a taco shell, and then dipped in rich chocolate and crunchy nuts. Pure genius, right? The Choco Taco wasn’t just an ice cream; it was a summertime staple, a childhood memory waiting to happen.
Invented in Philadelphia way back in 1983, it quickly conquered mobile food vendors before making its way into grocery store chains by the mid-1990s. Its popularity even crossed borders, delighting markets in Italy and Sweden, and it even evolved to include a cookies and cream version. For a time, you could even grab one at some Taco Bell locations, which just felt like a match made in dessert heaven. It truly had a global reach and an undeniable presence.
However, in July of 2022, Klondike dropped the bombshell: the Choco Taco was being discontinued. The reason? The company stated they needed to focus their attention on consumer interests in other areas. For many of us, this was a devastating blow, a personal loss of an iconic summertime dessert. Seriously, the loss of this one is the one I take the hardest – many a childhood afternoon at the local pool found me paying a dollar for one of these at the snack shack during a break from lifeguarding.
2. **Popsicle Bubble Gum Swirl**Now, bubble gum as an ice cream flavor can be a bit controversial, we get it. But for a glorious period, Popsicle Bubble Gum Swirl ice pops (sometimes also known as “Cotton Candy Swirl”) were an absolute treasure! Ice cream vendors made sure these vibrant treats were stocked, ready for their summer afternoon trips around every neighborhood, bringing smiles and sticky fingers to kids everywhere.
This frozen snack was instantly recognizable with its striking blue and pink color palette, swirled in a pattern that looked more like tiger stripes than dainty candy stripes. It might have only had a few devoted fans, but those fans were passionate! The company itself recognizes the powerful impression these brightly hued treats left on its clientele, which is a testament to its memorable nature. It wasn’t just a treat; it was a visual spectacle.
In a ray of hope for its loyalists, Popsicle actually offers a request form on its website where you can petition to bring back Bubble Gum Swirl. This also applies to other discontinued favorites like Candy Center Crunch and Vampire’s Deadly Secret. So, if you’re out there still dreaming of those electric blue and pink swirls, there’s a chance your voice could help resurrect this divisive but deeply cherished classic.
Remember Baskin Robbins Apple Pie A La Mode? This comforting flavor, a delicious ice cream rendition of a classic dessert, first appeared in 1976 and was fondly reintroduced in 2006, truly capturing the essence of grandma’s kitchen.
The widely beloved ice cream manufacturer has certainly tried other apple pie-inspired creations since, like their Inside Out Apple Pie and Apple Cider Donut flavors. But for the true connoisseurs, nothing quite measured up to the original A La Mode. It was special because it wasn’t just apple-flavored ice cream; it was packed with real pieces of perfectly baked pie crust, luscious cinnamon-flavored caramel ribbons, and genuine chunks of apple. It was a symphony of textures and flavors that evoked pure comfort.
Despite its reasonable success and patriotic appeal, this pie-inspired flavor sadly made its way into Baskin Robbins’ ominous “Deep Freeze” of flavorful favorites, never to be seen in stores again. This flavor vault also holds other dearly departed treats like Boston Creme Pie, Fluffernut, and Root Beer Float. A brief “Big Thaw” event in 2013 allowed customers to vote for temporary revivals, but Apple Pie A La Mode hasn’t seen the light of day since, leaving a cinnamon-shaped hole in many hearts.
4. **Blue Bunny Red Carpet Red Velvet Cake**Prepare yourself for a flavor that sounds so decadently delicious, it’s hard to believe it ever got the boot. Imagine a red velvet cake flavored ice cream, beautifully swirled with a rich, tangy cream cheese frosting flavored ice cream, and then – wait for it – scattered with real chunks of red velvet cake throughout! Seriously, how could something so phenomenally good be put on the chopping block?
Blue Bunny and Duff Goldman teamed up in 2011 to create Red Carpet Red Velvet Cake, a luxurious, cake-inspired ice cream that became a hit with fans of both ice cream and the famed Food Network personality.
However, this exquisite flavor had a too-quick run. It wasn’t even widely available, sold only in a limited number of stores nationwide. The promotion only lasted about a year before Blue Bunny decided to retire the flavor, along with its other partnership flavors with Goldman, such as I Do I Do Wedding Cake and Chocolate Lovers Triple Chocolate Cake. So, for those who tasted it, the memory remains, but the cartons are gone from supermarket shelves forever.
5. **Popsicle Sprinklers Ice Cream Bars**Is there an easier recipe for widespread popularity than vanilla ice cream dipped in chocolate and then generously rolled in tiny, vibrant rainbow-colored sprinkles? We think not! This sounds like a dessert dream come true, a simple yet undeniably joyful treat that would surely be a fan favorite for ages. It was a textural and visual delight, appealing to anyone with a sweet tooth.
Indeed, Popsicle Sprinklers Ice Cream Bars were a crunchy fan favorite, enjoying nearly 10 years of production throughout the ’90s. Yet, despite what seemed like an obvious formula for success, Popsicle made the bewildering decision to discontinue this beloved treat in the early 2000s. It was a perplexing move that left many dessert devotees scratching their heads, wondering why such a perfect combination was taken away.
Even today, many online pleas and petitions beg for the return of the Sprinklers bar, but alas, it doesn’t look like this one will be making a comeback. Similarly sprinkle-coated Popsicle Micro Pops also have a crowd of online devotees awaiting their return, but that doesn’t look likely either. As a brand spokesperson once explained, it’s “a necessary but unfortunate part of this is we sometimes must discontinue products in order to ensure we can offer customers the best variety of treats nationwide.” In the meantime, Popsicle lovers will just have to content themselves with the tried and true Spider-Man Character Pop.
6. **Dreyer’s/Edy’s Frozen Custard (Chocolate Malt)**Ah, frozen custard! A richer, creamier cousin to traditional ice cream, and Dreyer’s/Edy’s decided to bless us with their own line in 2015. Sadly, this delicious venture was short-lived, with the entire line trickling into nonexistence after only about a year on shelves. It was a fleeting moment of “extra thick and creamy” bliss that’s now just a memory.
The company never explained why this popular flavor was discontinued, but it seems Dreyer’s/Edy’s shifted its focus to its successful Slow Churned line, leaving a creamy, custard-shaped void that can’t quite be filled.
While the frozen custards were still in circulation, flavors like Old Fashioned Vanilla and Chocolate Malt gained serious footholds. Though some mildly criticized them for not being particularly risky flavors, leaning into traditional dessert profiles certainly attracted attention for a time. It’s hard to say no to a Snickerdoodle frozen custard, after all, and Peanut Butter Pie and Salted Caramel Pretzel drew on Dreyer’s/Edy’s long history of adding chunks of sweets. The Mint Cookies ‘N Cream combined two longtime sellers, mint chocolate chip and cookies and cream, a true match made in heaven. Unfortunately, none of these custard flavors are available in stores today.
7. **Starbucks Java Chip Ice Cream**Starbucks ice cream seems like an easy win, right? With the coffee giant’s legendary penchant for sugary sweet Frappuccino recipes, diving into the world of caffeine-friendly ice cream felt like the most natural next step imaginable. Who wouldn’t want to enjoy their favorite coffee-shop flavors in a scoopable, frozen format? It was a genius idea that seemed destined for greatness.
Originally introduced through a partnership with Dreyer’s/Edy’s in 1996, Starbucks Java Chip ice cream later moved to Unilever in 2009 when Dreyer’s/Edy’s was overhauling their selection. This switch brought even more cafe-inspired ice cream goodies to the freezer aisle: Caramel Macchiato, Mocha Frappuccino, Coffee, and the newly formulated Java Chip Frappuccino ice cream. They even had a seasonal push with a limited edition Peppermint Mocha ice cream flavor in 2010.
But then, in 2013, Starbucks quit the ice cream game for good, preferring instead to focus on their bakery selection and, of course, their core coffee business. Java Chip ice cream hasn’t been seen in stores since. The closest you’ll get now is ordering the Java Chip Frappuccino itself – and maybe, just maybe, adding a scoop of vanilla ice cream to it to create your own DIY version. It’s not the same, but it’s a valiant effort to recapture that lost frozen magic!
Brace yourselves, ice cream detectives, as we delve deeper into discontinued delights, uncovering seven more legendary ice cream and gelato creations cruelly removed from shelves, prompting fan pleas for their return.
8. **Turkey Hill Strawberry Rhubarb Pie**Talk about a flavor that screams “homemade comfort”! Turkey Hill’s Strawberry Rhubarb Pie ice cream was a delightful blend of strawberry ice cream, artfully swirled with rich strawberry and rhubarb ribbons, and generously peppered with chunks of crumbly shortbread cookie. It was like enjoying a slice of freshly baked pie, but in a perfectly scoopable, frozen form. This unique and utterly delicious flavor was a cherished part of Turkey Hill’s lineup from 1996 until 2001, leaving a sweet, tangy, and textural memory for many.
The love for Turkey Hill’s Strawberry Rhubarb Pie ice cream persisted even after its disappearance, nearly making a comeback in their 2017 Ultimate Flavor Tournament, though it ultimately lost to Caramel Brownie Overload.
While you can’t buy this specific pint anymore, dedicated fans can try recreating the lost classic at the Turkey Hill Ice Cream Experience in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where they offer a ‘make your own flavor’ workshop.
9. **Trader Joe’s Salted Caramel Gelato**Trader Joe’s is famous for its ever-evolving inventory, constantly rotating new and exciting products in and out based on seasonality and customer demand. But for many, the discontinuation of their Salted Caramel Gelato in 2016, less than two years after its 2014 launch, was a head-scratcher of epic proportions. How could something so perfectly balanced—sweet, salty, and incredibly smooth—just vanish?
For fans still craving that specific Trader Joe’s magic, the closest current option is their Hold the Dairy Mini Frozen Dessert Cones in Salted Caramel. However, many loyal customers will tell you it’s simply not the same, as the cone version is rice milk-based and lacks that rich, creamy gelato texture. Other suggestions include pairing their French Vanilla ice cream with a drizzle of Fleur de Sel Caramel Sauce or topping it with crumbled Caramel Palmiers, which sounds pretty divine, but still, not the original.
For those still craving the authentic Trader Joe’s gelato experience, their Strawberries & Cream flavor remains a staple, but the quest for the perfectly salty-sweet frozen dream of their Salted Caramel Gelato continues.
10. **Häagen-Dazs Baileys Irish Cream**When it comes to adult-friendly dessert flavors, Baileys Irish Cream feels like a match made in heaven for ice cream. The rich, creamy liqueur with its notes of whiskey, coffee, and cocoa translates beautifully into a frozen treat, making Häagen-Dazs’ decision to discontinue it a truly perplexing one for many fans. The disappointment was palpable, with many taking to Twitter in 2018 to lament its loss, begging for its return.
Though the original Baileys Irish Cream ice cream is likely gone forever, Häagen-Dazs offers a delicious successor with their Irish Cream Brownie flavor, featuring whiskey, coffee, and cocoa notes enhanced by brownie chunks and chocolate swirls.
The Baileys Irish Cream flavor wasn’t the only one to be retired from Häagen-Dazs’ extensive lineup. Beloved flavors like Crème Brulée and Peanut Butter Salted Fudge also had somewhat limited runs before being pulled from production. This constant innovation is part of the brand’s strategy to make room for new and exciting offerings, such as their Black and White Cookie ice cream, Bourbon Vanilla Bean Truffle, and their popular selections of ice cream bars and pre-made cones.
11. **Mounds Ice Cream Bars**Ah, the Mounds Ice Cream Bar – a coconut lover’s dream swiftly taken from us! Launched in 2012, these treats had a tragically short lifespan, being discontinued just three years later. Imagine: light and sweet coconut ice cream, generously dunked in rich dark chocolate, creating a larger, colder, and utterly delicious version of the classic Mounds candy bar. It sounds like a formula for success, doesn’t it?
Interestingly, while Mounds got its own ice cream bar, its equally famous counterpart, Almond Joy, never received a signature frozen treat of its own, despite many brands attempting to replicate that iconic balance of coconut, almonds, and milk chocolate. The Mounds bar, however, was a somewhat niche flavor that, unfortunately, didn’t sell as successfully as anticipated. Perhaps the distinct flavor profile wasn’t for everyone.
Another challenge for the Mounds Ice Cream Bar was its form factor. Being a bar rather than on a stick, it tended to melt a bit faster than its competitive desserts, which might have contributed to its decline. While the original Mounds candy bars are thankfully still readily available in stores for your dark chocolate and coconut fix, the ice cream variation remains a sweet, frozen memory for those who got to experience its brief but glorious run.
12. **Talenti Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Gelato**Talenti has truly mastered the art of the visible dessert with their easy-to-reuse clear plastic tubs, beautifully showcasing swirls of gelato layered with toppings and other treats. Yet, even with their knack for creating eye-catching delights, their Oatmeal Raisin Cookie combo just didn’t quite capture the widespread interest that some of their other creations did. It was a flavor that had all the right components, but perhaps not enough buzz.
This particular gelato was a symphony of warmth and spice, featuring real chunks of oatmeal cookie and plump whole raisins folded into a deliciously spiced gelato, all sweetened with notes of brown sugar and molasses. It launched in 2015, offering a truly unique and comforting profile, but sadly, it was discontinued just a few years later. It now resides among the many treats we are not likely to see gracing supermarket shelves again.
Talenti keeps a running list of its retired flavors on its website, a veritable graveyard of nearly 50 ice cream, gelato, and sorbet creations. While some, like Ginger Matcha, might seem like niche choices, the disappearance of flavors like Vanilla Chai and Tiramisu still leaves fans scratching their heads. Here’s hoping that, along with the beloved Oatmeal Raisin Cookie, these delicious departures might one day resurface!
13. **Talenti Banana Caramel Crunch Gelato Layers**Prepare your taste buds for another Talenti masterpiece that fans are desperately hoping will make a comeback: Banana Caramel Crunch Gelato Layers. This was not just a pint of ice cream; it was a meticulously crafted dessert concept delivered right in a jar. Every single spoonful promised a different adventure thanks to its distinctive and delicious layers, creating an eating experience far beyond your average scoop.
Imagine this: smooth banana pudding gelato, generously layered with rich dulce de leche, and studded with real chunks of crunchy pie crust throughout. It was a perfect harmony of creamy, sweet, and crunchy, ensuring that each bite offered a unique combination of its components. This fully developed dessert concept was a true standout, showcasing Talenti’s commitment to layered indulgence.
While Banana Caramel Crunch may be gone, Talenti thankfully still produces 16 other incredible options from their Gelato Layers line. These continue to offer visibly distinct layers of everything from oat crisps in Black Raspberry Vanilla Parfait to graham cracker cookie pieces in Chocolate Cherry Cheesecake. Can’t decide which layered wonder is for you? Talenti even has a handy quiz on its website to help you find your “perfect pint.”
14. **Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream Supermoon**Ah, Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream – a brand known for its incredibly inventive and often whimsical flavors. In March of 2017, Jeni’s stirred up a delightful buzz on Instagram with the announcement of Supermoon, a nostalgic, two-toned ice cream. It was specifically marketed to evoke childhood memories, conjuring images of those beloved dehydrated cereal marshmallows, much like the iconic, colorful shapes found in Lucky Charms. Pure magic in a pint!
The description alone was enough to make any marshmallow enthusiast swoon. The yellow half of Supermoon was described as tasting “like the most marshmallowy marshmallow ever,” a promise of intense, sweet fluffiness. The blue side, however, offered a more “unexpected” twist, with notes of “sweet and floral candied violet,” a flavor Jeni herself believed tasted remarkably like Lucky Charms marshmallows. It was truly two distinct takes on marshmallow, brilliantly combined.
Even years later, the yearning for Supermoon persists. Commenters continue to flood Jeni’s introductory Instagram post with requests, begging the brand to bring this unique flavor back to stores. While customer service responses from Jeni’s encourage fans to keep their feedback coming, ensuring that their R+D folks know which flavors are missed most, the official word is that the brand currently has “no plans to resurface Supermoon.” Oh, the heartbreak of a truly splendid, yet dearly departed, flavor!
We’ve journeyed through discontinued ice cream flavors, remembering childhood classics and gourmet masterpieces, but these 14 flavors are just a glimpse of sweet memories lost; however, fan demand ensures they’re not forgotten, and perhaps one day, a flavor will rise from the ‘flavor graveyard’ for an encore!
