You know that feeling, right? You’ve just finished another season of Netflix’s ‘You,’ and you’re left with that deliciously unsettling blend of fascination and dread. Joe Goldberg, our charmingly deranged protagonist, has a way of getting under your skin, making you question everything you thought you knew about love, obsession, and just how far someone will go for what they want. It’s a wild ride, and let’s be honest, we can’t get enough of it! We all love the intense psychological games Joe plays, don’t we?
The magic of ‘You’ isn’t just in the suspense; it’s in the unique, unsettling perspective it offers. We’re invited into the mind of a serial killer, seeing the world through his twisted logic, even as we’re horrified by his actions. This deep dive into psychological manipulation, combined with genuinely thrilling plots, makes for some truly compulsive viewing. If you’re anything like us, you’re constantly on the hunt for your next fix of that particular brand of dark entertainment, craving those complex characters and moral grey areas.
Well, buckle up, because we’ve scoured the streaming landscape – literally, the best of the best – to bring you a list of shows and movies that capture that same thrilling, mind-bending, sometimes truly disturbing energy that makes ‘You’ such a runaway hit. Get ready to add some serious suspense to your watchlist! We’re talking about titles that feature complex villains, deep psychological dives, and twists that will leave you gasping. Here are 7 fantastic picks to kick off your next binge, guaranteed to scratch that ‘You’ itch.
1. **Dexter**
When it comes to shows that dive deep into the mind of a serial killer, ‘Dexter’ truly set the standard for a long, long time. There is no franchise that’s run longer and found its second wind more often following this unique killer’s perspective. It offers a fascinating parallel to Joe Goldberg’s internal monologues, giving us a peek behind the charming facade of a seemingly normal guy with a deadly secret.
Based on the novels by Jeff Lindsay, the show revolves around Dexter Morgan, brilliantly portrayed by Michael C. Hall. He’s a forensic technician in Miami by day, meticulously analyzing blood spatter, but by night, he secretly moonlights as a vigilante serial killer. His mission? To take on other local murderers who have escaped the law, adhering to his own strict, if twisted, code of justice. It’s a dark dance with morality, to say the least.
What makes ‘Dexter’ so compelling is the darkly humorous perspective that Hall brings to the character. Along with a whole line of equally lethal antagonists, this series makes for consistently entertaining television. Like Joe Goldberg, Dexter Morgan puts on a charming front to conceal his deadly side, blending seamlessly into society while secretly indulging his murderous proclivities. It’s a masterclass in duality that will keep you guessing.
While some might argue that the series perhaps ‘should have ended sooner than it did,’ Hall’s performance as the killer has always been its undeniable highlight. The show’s various iterations, from the original series to the revival ‘Dexter: New Blood’ and the prequel ‘Dexter: Original Sin,’ all benefit from his magnetic portrayal. It remains a standout in Showtime’s original programming for years, proving its enduring appeal to thriller fans.
2.Before he was starring in major Hollywood blockbusters and commanding the big screen, British actor Idris Elba delivered an intense, career-defining performance as the title character in the crime procedural ‘Luther.’ If you’re looking for a detective who grapples with truly terrifying killers and walks a fine line between justice and obsession, this is the show for you. Luther’s world is a gritty, dangerous place, much like the twisted realities Joe Goldberg creates, offering a similarly captivating dark charm.
Elba stars as London police detective John Luther, whose work in the major crimes unit usually pits him against terrifying killers on the loose in the city. But it’s not just the cases that take their toll; Luther’s work takes an immense toll on his well-being and personal life, pushing him to his limits. A crucial and utterly fascinating element of the series is his ‘odd relationship’ with the psychopathic killer Alice Morgan, portrayed by the brilliant Ruth Wilson, a dynamic that will keep you absolutely glued to the screen.
Simply put, ‘Luther’ is heralded as ‘one of the best crime TV shows of all time,’ and it’s easy to see why. The intense procedural story is elevated immeasurably by Elba’s powerful and intense performance. A major part of that intensity and effectiveness comes from how truly scary the show can be at times, establishing how dangerous its villains are, making every chase and confrontation feel incredibly high-stakes and genuinely chilling.
Many episodes feature a steadily mounting dread as the killers stalk their prey, underscoring how important it is for Luther to stop these maniacs before more harm is done. Thanks to its strong showing throughout its entire run, culminating in the 2023 continuation movie ‘Luther: The Fallen Sun,’ this series is the perfect showcase for how well Elba can command a scene and infuse a character with such compelling gravitas.
3. **Pretty Little Liars (2010)**
If you’re into the ‘You’ style of voyeurism, secrets, and a shadowy figure pulling strings, then the 2010 adaptation of author Sara Shepard’s popular young adult novel series, ‘Pretty Little Liars,’ is an absolute must-watch. This show blends coming-of-age drama with a persistent, thrilling mystery that keeps you on the edge of your seat, much like trying to figure out Joe’s next move.
The show kicks off revolving around a group of estranged friends who separated in the wake of the sudden disappearance of their mutual friend and clique leader. One year after this disappearance, the group reunites under unsettling circumstances when they begin receiving threatening messages from an anonymous source, known only as ‘A,’ revealing their most personal and damning secrets. The friends set out to identify their tormentor, but the identity of ‘A’ changes, with later seasons involving different antagonists that constantly challenge this close-knit, often fractured, group.
What starts out as a coming-of-age drama with a distinct ‘voyeuristic edge’ quickly ‘grew more complex as it progressed.’ While more of a mystery than an overt thriller initially, the series truly thrived on the ‘messy interpersonal dynamics’ between its main characters, making their relationships and rivalries as captivating as the overarching mystery. It’s all about trust, betrayal, and the deep, dark secrets that bind them.
The original series even featured a ‘five-year time jump’ that gave the show ‘its second wind,’ delving into slightly more mature subject matter and more intricate plotlines. ‘Pretty Little Liars’ is an effective teen drama that rose above its contemporaries and remains a compelling twist on the genre. It’s perfect for anyone who loves a good mystery with plenty of twists and turns, especially when everyone has something to hide.
4. **The Killing (2011)**For those who appreciate the methodical, often bleak, but utterly gripping investigative thrillers that peel back layers of a crime to reveal deeper societal rot, ‘The Killing’ is your next obsession. This American adaptation of the 2007 Danish crime series delves into mysteries with a moody atmosphere that perfectly complements its complex characters and shocking revelations, making it a natural fit for ‘You’ fans who crave depth.
The remake’s first two seasons echo its European source material, focusing intensely on police detectives Sarah Linden (Mireille Enos) and Stephen Holder (Joel Kinnaman) as they investigate the brutal murder of a Seattle teenager. As they dig deeper, the two detectives discover the girl has far-reaching ties, including unsettling connections with local politician Darren Richmond (Billy Campbell). The intricate web of deceit and power struggles will leave you questioning everyone, just like Joe’s intricate manipulations.
While the decision to extend the initial murder mystery to two seasons ‘may have impacted the show’s initial momentum,’ ‘The Killing’ is still ‘clearly a cut above most crime shows.’ Enos and Kinnaman make a remarkably ‘strong crime-solving duo,’ their contrasting personalities creating a compelling dynamic. The series also delivers an appropriately ‘moody atmosphere’ for its Pacific Northwestern setting, enhancing the feeling of a city shrouded in secrets and rain.
But more than just the stylish staging and thrills, the series explores the ‘heartbreaking impact of the murders being committed,’ particularly in its opening mystery. It doesn’t shy away from the emotional devastation a crime leaves in its wake. ‘Haunting in its presentation and superbly acted all-around,’ ‘The Killing’ is a rare remake that shines just as brightly as the original show, offering a powerful, emotionally resonant viewing experience that delves into the consequences of dark deeds.
5. **The Following**
If the idea of Joe Goldberg inspiring a legion of loyal, equally unhinged followers sends a shiver down your spine, then get ready for ‘The Following.’ This 2013 thriller series, starring Kevin Bacon and developed by ‘Scream’ creator Kevin Williamson, is built on the chilling premise of ‘sinister cults of personality,’ making it a dark and intense ride that ‘You’ fans will undoubtedly appreciate.
Bacon plays former FBI agent Ryan Hardy, a man haunted by his past. He is forced to return to action when notorious serial killer Joe Carroll (James Purefoy), whom Hardy originally apprehended, escapes from prison. What makes Carroll truly terrifying is that he doesn’t just escape; he gains a ‘zealous following of fanatical murderers,’ all dedicated to his twisted ideology. This brings a whole new level of menace to the traditional serial killer narrative.
Hardy quickly discovers that Carroll’s escape and his growing cult are all part of an elaborate scheme. Carroll is meticulously orchestrating events to regain his freedom and, more sinisterly, to pursue a personal vendetta against Hardy for arresting him years prior. The show’s later seasons continue this pattern, following different dangerous cults and serial killers, all pursued by Hardy and his colleagues in the FBI, constantly raising the stakes and the body count.
For a show that initially aired on network television, ‘The Following’ pushed the boundaries of ‘graphic content for the platform at that time,’ so be prepared for a violent and visceral viewing experience. Between the gratuitous carnage are ‘strong performances from Bacon and Purefoy,’ who complement each other perfectly in this intense cat-and-mouse game. Airing for three seasons, ‘The Following’ is a vicious procedural that leans into a more horror-driven direction, making it an excellent choice for those craving high-octane psychological thrills.
6. **Bates Motel**
Ever wondered what makes a monster? ‘Bates Motel’ offers a fascinating, and deeply unsettling, look into the origins of one of cinema’s most iconic villains, Norman Bates. This 2013 A&E series acts as a prequel to Alfred Hitchcock’s iconic 1960 movie ‘Psycho,’ chronicling the ‘blood-soaked upbringing’ of proto-slasher Norman, giving ‘You’ fans a deep dive into the psychological making of a killer.
Freddie Highmore delivers a truly remarkable performance as Norman, who is a teenager at the start of the series, alongside the equally brilliant Vera Farmiga playing his ‘dangerously unstable mother Norma.’ The mother and son duo open up the Bates Motel at a remote Oregon location, hoping for a fresh start. However, they soon find themselves drawn into a widening web of murder, secrets, and local corruption that slowly unravels their already fragile sanity.
As the series progresses, Norma becomes increasingly fearful of what Norman is capable of as his mental health steadily deteriorates, fueling his capacity for violence. The show excels at exploring the ‘creepy familial dynamics’ between Norman and Norma, showcasing how their intensely codependent and toxic relationship lays the foundation for Norman’s eventual transformation. It’s a tragic and terrifying character study.
Highmore and Farmiga anchor the entire series, knowing precisely when to find the ‘painful humanity’ of their characters and when to go full throttle with its ‘bloody premise.’ As Norman inexorably moves towards his slasher destiny, the show only grows stronger every step of the way, making their dynamic more fragile and explosive. ‘Bates Motel’ is a ‘fascinating psychological deep dive’ into one of cinema’s most iconic killers, bringing the dark drama and lethal thrills to reinvigorate the ‘Psycho’ franchise for a new generation, exploring the origins of madness.
7.If you thought Joe Goldberg was a sophisticated manipulator, wait until you meet Dr. Hannibal Lecter. ‘Hannibal’ takes the concept of a charming, intelligent villain to an entirely different, culinary, level. As far as iconic pop culture serial killers go, there are few that are more recognizable than Hannibal Lecter, created by author Thomas Harris, and this series gives him a chillingly beautiful portrayal that will make you question your taste in terrifying characters.
The cultured cannibal headlined the 2013 NBC series ‘Hannibal,’ with Mads Mikkelsen delivering a mesmerizing performance as Lecter, joined by Hugh Dancy as the brilliant but fragile FBI profiler Will Graham. Initially, they work closely together, a strange intellectual partnership forged in the pursuit of other serial killers. However, Lecter’s true nature gradually reveals itself, putting a ‘particularly terrifying twist on procedural TV’ and making every interaction fraught with subtle menace.
This leads to the former associates being ‘pitted against each other,’ despite all their commonalities and deeply shared rapport, blurring the lines between hero and villain, sanity and madness. ‘Hannibal’ ‘does the previously unthinkable’ and brings the franchise out from under the shadow of Anthony Hopkins’ award-winning portrayal of Lecter, creating a unique and deeply disturbing interpretation that stands on its own merits.
Each of the show’s three seasons ups the ante, infusing its mystery thriller sensibilities with an ‘increasingly unsettling mood’ and breathtaking visual artistry. At its core, the story is often described as the ‘bad romance’ between Graham and Lecter, a relationship that is unconsummated but ‘no less passionate amidst the blood and fury.’ It’s a psychological chess match that leaves you breathless.
Years after its cancellation, ‘Hannibal’ still has fans ‘in a chokehold’ waiting for further turns from Mikkelsen as the ravenous Lecter. Its unique blend of psychological horror, exquisite aesthetics, and profound exploration of the human psyche makes it an unforgettable watch and a perfect companion for anyone who appreciates the darker, more intelligent side of thrillers.
Ready for more? Because we are! If the first seven picks just whetted your appetite for dark thrills and complex characters, you’re in luck. We’re diving even deeper, moving ‘Beyond Joe Goldberg’ to unpack seven more captivating series and movies that promise to keep your heart pounding. Get ready to explore cults, teen mysteries, and moral dilemmas so twisted, you’ll be questioning everything! Your next binge-watching session is about to get a serious upgrade of twists and suspense. Let’s do this!
8. **Dirty John**
If you thought Joe Goldberg’s manipulative ways were unsettling, then prepare for ‘Dirty John,’ a title that’s probably the most similar to ‘You’ on Netflix, but with a terrifying twist: it’s a true story. Yes, you read that right – this isn’t fiction, which makes the psychological games at play even more chilling. It plunges you headfirst into a world where a young woman falls for a handsome doctor, only to find herself embroiled in a game where psychological manipulation reigns supreme.
The series pulls you into the whirlwind romance that quickly devolves into a nightmare, showcasing how quickly charm can turn into control. The narrative masterfully unravels the layers of deceit, mirroring ‘You’ in its exploration of how a seemingly perfect relationship can hide the darkest intentions. It’s a deep dive into the psyche of a predator, leaving you to wonder how such events could genuinely unfold.
While the first season is a complete, harrowing tale, another season of ‘Dirty John’ is reportedly on the way to Netflix. This future installment will likely offer a fresh, yet equally compelling, detour from the initial story. It’s definitely one to watch if you crave that intense, suffocating feeling of being caught in a web of psychological mind games, proving that truth can sometimes be stranger, and scarier, than fiction, much like Joe’s own twisted reality.
9.Do you absolutely live for thrillers that make your brain do gymnastics? Then ‘What/If’ is about to become your new obsession, a fantastic show to binge through that’s all about those juicy moral conundrums. This series stars the incredible Renée Zellweger, who, across its 10 captivating episodes, challenges viewers to consider how one single decision can ripple out and have a massive, unforeseen impact on everyone involved, forcing you to ponder life’s ‘what ifs’.
It’s a high-stakes drama that explores the intricate dance between ambition, ethics, and consequences, making you ponder the ‘what ifs’ of every choice. The show delves into scenarios where characters are pushed to their limits, forcing them to make impossible choices with even more impossible outcomes. Much like ‘You,’ it shines a spotlight on the darker corners of human nature and the lengths people will go to achieve their desires.
The series definitely got rave reviews, and honestly, it’s easy to see why. The performances are gripping, and the twists keep you guessing with every turn. While its future with a second season remains uncertain, the existing episodes offer a complete, thrilling ride that delivers on its promise of psychological suspense. Get ready for a thought-provoking watch that will stick with you long after the credits roll.
10. **Elite**
Looking for a dose of ‘You’-esque secrets and a persistent mystery but want to switch things up with an international flair? Then you absolutely cannot miss the Spanish series ‘Elite.’ It’s a rich, intense, and oh-so-dramatic look into a private school where a clash between new, poorer students and the established elite spirals into a pretty horrifying thriller series. Talk about high school drama taken to a whole new level!
This show masterfully blends teen drama with a gripping murder mystery, making every character a suspect and every secret a potential motive. Like ‘Pretty Little Liars,’ it thrives on the intricate interpersonal dynamics and hidden agendas, but with an added layer of dark suspense. You’ll be captivated by the opulent settings and the even more opulent lies that underpin the students’ lives.
The tension steadily builds, much like Joe Goldberg’s methodical pursuit of his obsessions, as the students navigate a world where privilege hides dark truths. At the time of publishing, Netflix was even scheduled to release season 3 in March 2020, proving its enduring popularity. If you’re a fan of watching how wealth and power corrupt, all while trying to solve a thrilling whodunit, ‘Elite’ is your next binge.
11. **Gypsy**
Prepare yourself for a truly unique psychological thriller that Netflix created with ‘Gypsy,’ a series that pushes the boundaries of ethical boundaries. This show dives deep into the unsettling life of a therapist who begins to subtly, and then not-so-subtly, infiltrate her clients’ lives. If Joe Goldberg’s boundary-crossing fascinates you, then this show will have you glued to the screen.
The series excels at exploring the moral rights and wrongs of such intimate professional betrayals, making you question the very nature of trust and connection. While it wisely doesn’t escalate to the graphic violence seen in ‘You,’ the psychological implications are equally profound and disturbing. It’s all about the slow burn of manipulation and the dangerous thrill of living a double life.
What makes ‘Gypsy’ so compelling is its nuanced portrayal of a character who starts with good intentions but gradually becomes consumed by her desires to connect and control. The show is a masterclass in showing how ethical lines blur and disappear, leaving a trail of emotional wreckage. It’s a fascinating, albeit dark, character study.
Sadly, only one season of ‘Gypsy’ hit Netflix, and it wasn’t renewed for further episodes, which is truly a shame given its compelling premise. However, that single season is a powerful, self-contained exploration of psychological infiltration that will leave a lasting impression and scratch that ‘You’ itch for moral complexity.
12. **Monster: The Ed Gein Story**
If you’re fascinated by the truly dark origins of serial killers and the chilling realities behind them, then ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ is an absolute must-watch. This highly anticipated series from Netflix, which quickly shot to #5 on the list of 25 Most Popular TV Shows Right Now, promises a deep, unsettling dive into the psyche of one of America’s most infamous figures. Just like ‘You’ lets us into Joe’s twisted mind, this series aims to explore the depths of another terrifying individual.
While the context details are primarily centered on its popularity and stellar cast – featuring Charlie Hunnam, Suzanna Son, Tom Hollander, and Laurie Metcalf – the title alone speaks volumes. It’s clear that this show ventures into the territory of genuine psychological horror, chronicling the life and crimes of Ed Gein, whose horrific actions inspired countless fictional villains. This makes it a direct and intense companion for fans of ‘You’s villain-centric storytelling.
The draw of ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ lies in its promise to peel back the layers of a truly monstrous individual, much like ‘You’ humanizes, yet condemns, Joe Goldberg. It’s about understanding the ‘how’ and ‘why’ behind unthinkable acts, offering a chilling glimpse into the unraveling of a mind. If you appreciate shows that don’t shy away from the darker aspects of human nature and crime, this series is calling your name.
Expect a gripping and possibly unsettling experience that leaves you questioning the boundaries of sanity. The presence of a strong ensemble cast suggests a compelling narrative, delivering not just frights but a complex portrayal of a real-life horror. This is definitely one to add to your watchlist if you’re seeking to explore the darker side of true crime, wrapped in a dramatic series.
13. **The Girlfriend**
Ready for a twisty thriller that will have you guessing everyone’s motivations? Then clear your schedule for ‘The Girlfriend,’ a Prime Video series that made a splash, earning its spot as #13 on the 25 Most Popular TV Shows Right Now. Starring the incredible Robin Wright and Olivia Cooke, critics consensus proudly states they are “terrific at behaving badly,” setting the stage for some serious drama and suspense that ‘You’ fans will devour.
Based on author Michelle Frances’ psychological thriller, the story immediately hooks you: Robin Wright plays an uber-wealthy woman whose son introduces her to his new girlfriend, portrayed by Olivia Cooke. From the get-go, Mom has her suspicions, believing the girlfriend’s motivations are less than genuine. But here’s the kicker: is Mom right, or is she just being paranoid? This psychological dance between suspicion and reality is exactly what makes the show so compelling, blurring the lines of trust and deception.
The series brilliantly plays on themes of trust, deceit, and the lengths people will go to protect their own, or what they believe is theirs. It’s a masterclass in tension, as every interaction is fraught with hidden meanings and unspoken agendas. The ‘Critics Consensus’ notes that it’s a “twisty thriller that strains credulity with so much aplomb that audiences won’t mind,” which is basically a green light for anyone who loves a good, juicy mystery.
What’s truly captivating is the dynamic between these powerful women, each with their own secrets and desires, mirroring the complex and often destructive relationships in ‘You.’ “Whatever’s really going on here, it looks like no one is going to end up unscathed,” and honestly, that’s exactly what we want in a thriller, isn’t it? Get ready for a ride filled with secrets, suspicion, and stylish performances.
14. **Wayward**
Rounding out our thrilling list is ‘Wayward,’ a series that shot straight to #1 on the 25 Most Popular TV Shows Right Now! If you’re into ‘You’ for its eerie mysteries and unexpected turns, then this thriller is absolutely going to intrigue you. The ‘Critics Consensus’ calls it “an eerie mystery that eschews easy answers,” promising a storyline that keeps you on your toes, much like trying to predict Joe Goldberg’s next move.
Starring Mae Martin, Toni Collette, Sarah Gadon, and Patrick J. Adams, ‘Wayward’ features Toni Collette delivering a “committed performance” that helps keep this series utterly captivating. While it might occasionally feel “as listless as its title,” according to critics, it consistently delivers “surprising twists” that prevent it from ever truly losing its grip on your attention. It’s a show that understands the power of slow-burn suspense.
The atmosphere of ‘Wayward’ is perfect for those who enjoy mysteries with a lingering sense of unease. It’s about peeling back layers, uncovering hidden truths, and navigating a narrative where nothing is quite what it seems. The eerie quality and commitment to ambiguity ensure that you’re always engaged, trying to piece together the puzzle right alongside the characters.
So, if you appreciate a thriller that offers more than just jump scares, delving into a complex web of intrigue and psychological depth, ‘Wayward’ is your next destination. It’s an intriguing ride that’s perfect for fans who love to dissect every clue and every character’s secret, making it a stellar addition to your ‘You’-inspired watchlist!
And there you have it, fellow thrill-seekers! From twisted therapists to eerie mysteries and true-crime terrors, this list is packed with shows and movies that capture the dark, irresistible charm of ‘You.’ Whether you’re craving more psychological manipulation, complex moral dilemmas, or just a good old-fashioned mystery that keeps you up all night, these picks are guaranteed to fill that Joe Goldberg-shaped void in your streaming schedule. So, grab your snacks, dim the lights, and prepare for some seriously suspenseful binge-watching that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
